From 5b4b006b432ac40ef4febb705dc8415b737bf8a9 Mon Sep 17 00:00:00 2001 From: Automotive Skills Autonomous Date: Tue, 2 Jun 2026 11:09:21 +0000 Subject: [PATCH] auto(polish): W23 #1 cs-concept-builder pass, regen STATUS, journal MIME-Version: 1.0 Content-Type: text/plain; charset=UTF-8 Content-Transfer-Encoding: 8bit Autonomous daily run. - W23 target #1 (issue #4, four-week carryover): re-audit against byte-identical archive, append W23 dated polish-log section - Three open DoD findings (CSR derivation / CAL allocation / CSI handoff trigger placement) all editorial β€” outside the autonomous-edit allowlist; W20 rewrite remains the human action - STATUS.md regen: domain rule-order fix so safety-program-* / safety-gate-* classify as program-mgmt not safety; fmeda / msa-gage / spc-chart added to safety / quality respectively; spread matches W22-RELEASE STATUS (safety=15, quality=10, program-mgmt=5, ...) - Fresh/stale flags shift: as of 2026-06-02 only autosar-swc and uds-services remain 🟒; rest of suite is 30d+ stale (2/74) Generated by automotive-skills-daily-standup scheduled task. --- STATUS.md | 81 +++++++-------- docs/AUTONOMOUS_LOG.md | 16 +++ docs/skill-polish-log/cs-concept-builder.md | 105 ++++++++++++++++++++ 3 files changed, 162 insertions(+), 40 deletions(-) diff --git a/STATUS.md b/STATUS.md index 8c27e61..ab2e689 100644 --- a/STATUS.md +++ b/STATUS.md @@ -1,6 +1,6 @@ # STATUS β€” Automotive Skills Suite -_Auto-regenerated by `automotive-skills-daily-standup` (2026-06-01 PLAN run)._ +_Auto-regenerated by `automotive-skills-daily-standup` (2026-06-02 POLISH run)._ **Total builders:** 76 Β· **Total reviewers:** 76 Β· **Paired:** 76 (100%) Β· **Orphans:** 0 @@ -8,58 +8,58 @@ _Auto-regenerated by `automotive-skills-daily-standup` (2026-06-01 PLAN run)._ |---|---|---|---|---| | `5-why-builder.skill` | quality | `5-why-checklist-reviewer.skill` | 2026-05-01 | 🟑 stale (30d) | | `8d-problem-solving-builder.skill` | quality | `8d-problem-solving-checklist-reviewer.skill` | 2026-05-01 | 🟑 stale (30d) | -| `a2l-builder.skill` | calibration | `a2l-checklist-reviewer.skill` | 2026-05-02 | 🟒 fresh | +| `a2l-builder.skill` | calibration | `a2l-checklist-reviewer.skill` | 2026-05-02 | 🟑 stale (30d) | | `apqp-plan-builder.skill` | quality | `apqp-plan-checklist-reviewer.skill` | 2026-05-01 | 🟑 stale (30d) | -| `arxml-system-builder.skill` | comms | `arxml-system-checklist-reviewer.skill` | 2026-05-02 | 🟒 fresh | +| `arxml-system-builder.skill` | comms | `arxml-system-checklist-reviewer.skill` | 2026-05-02 | 🟑 stale (30d) | | `aspice-assessment-builder.skill` | aspice | `aspice-assessment-checklist-reviewer.skill` | 2026-05-01 | 🟑 stale (30d) | | `aspice-gap-analysis-builder.skill` | aspice | `aspice-gap-analysis-checklist-reviewer.skill` | 2026-05-01 | 🟑 stale (30d) | | `aspice-improvement-plan-builder.skill` | aspice | `aspice-improvement-plan-checklist-reviewer.skill` | 2026-05-01 | 🟑 stale (30d) | | `aspice-process-evidence-builder.skill` | aspice | `aspice-process-evidence-checklist-reviewer.skill` | 2026-05-01 | 🟑 stale (30d) | -| `automotive-ethernet-builder.skill` | comms | `automotive-ethernet-checklist-reviewer.skill` | 2026-05-02 | 🟒 fresh | -| `autosar-adaptive-app-builder.skill` | autosar | `autosar-adaptive-app-checklist-reviewer.skill` | 2026-05-02 | 🟒 fresh | -| `autosar-bsw-config-builder.skill` | autosar | `autosar-bsw-config-checklist-reviewer.skill` | 2026-05-02 | 🟒 fresh | -| `autosar-composition-builder.skill` | autosar | `autosar-composition-checklist-reviewer.skill` | 2026-05-02 | 🟒 fresh | -| `autosar-rte-mapping-builder.skill` | autosar | `autosar-rte-mapping-checklist-reviewer.skill` | 2026-05-02 | 🟒 fresh | +| `automotive-ethernet-builder.skill` | comms | `automotive-ethernet-checklist-reviewer.skill` | 2026-05-02 | 🟑 stale (30d) | +| `autosar-adaptive-app-builder.skill` | autosar | `autosar-adaptive-app-checklist-reviewer.skill` | 2026-05-02 | 🟑 stale (30d) | +| `autosar-bsw-config-builder.skill` | autosar | `autosar-bsw-config-checklist-reviewer.skill` | 2026-05-02 | 🟑 stale (30d) | +| `autosar-composition-builder.skill` | autosar | `autosar-composition-checklist-reviewer.skill` | 2026-05-02 | 🟑 stale (30d) | +| `autosar-rte-mapping-builder.skill` | autosar | `autosar-rte-mapping-checklist-reviewer.skill` | 2026-05-02 | 🟑 stale (30d) | | `autosar-swc-builder.skill` | autosar | `autosar-swc-checklist-reviewer.skill` | 2026-05-21 | 🟒 fresh | -| `bus-load-analysis-builder.skill` | comms | `bus-load-analysis-checklist-reviewer.skill` | 2026-05-02 | 🟒 fresh | -| `calibration-data-exchange-builder.skill` | calibration | `calibration-data-exchange-checklist-reviewer.skill` | 2026-05-02 | 🟒 fresh | -| `cdd-builder.skill` | diagnostics | `cdd-checklist-reviewer.skill` | 2026-05-02 | 🟒 fresh | -| `change-impact-analysis-builder.skill` | program-mgmt | `change-impact-analysis-checklist-reviewer.skill` | 2026-05-02 | 🟒 fresh | -| `communication-matrix-builder.skill` | comms | `communication-matrix-checklist-reviewer.skill` | 2026-05-02 | 🟒 fresh | +| `bus-load-analysis-builder.skill` | comms | `bus-load-analysis-checklist-reviewer.skill` | 2026-05-02 | 🟑 stale (30d) | +| `calibration-data-exchange-builder.skill` | calibration | `calibration-data-exchange-checklist-reviewer.skill` | 2026-05-02 | 🟑 stale (30d) | +| `cdd-builder.skill` | diagnostics | `cdd-checklist-reviewer.skill` | 2026-05-02 | 🟑 stale (30d) | +| `change-impact-analysis-builder.skill` | program-mgmt | `change-impact-analysis-checklist-reviewer.skill` | 2026-05-02 | 🟑 stale (30d) | +| `communication-matrix-builder.skill` | comms | `communication-matrix-checklist-reviewer.skill` | 2026-05-02 | 🟑 stale (30d) | | `control-plan-builder.skill` | quality | `control-plan-checklist-reviewer.skill` | 2026-05-01 | 🟑 stale (30d) | | `cs-architecture-builder.skill` | cyber | `cs-architecture-checklist-reviewer.skill` | 2026-05-01 | 🟑 stale (30d) | | `cs-concept-builder.skill` | cyber | `cs-concept-checklist-reviewer.skill` | 2026-05-01 | 🟑 stale (30d) | | `cs-goals-builder.skill` | cyber | `cs-goals-checklist-reviewer.skill` | 2026-05-01 | 🟑 stale (30d) | -| `dbc-builder.skill` | comms | `dbc-checklist-reviewer.skill` | 2026-05-02 | 🟒 fresh | -| `dcm-builder.skill` | calibration | `dcm-checklist-reviewer.skill` | 2026-05-02 | 🟒 fresh | -| `dem-config-builder.skill` | diagnostics | `dem-config-checklist-reviewer.skill` | 2026-05-02 | 🟒 fresh | +| `dbc-builder.skill` | comms | `dbc-checklist-reviewer.skill` | 2026-05-02 | 🟑 stale (30d) | +| `dcm-builder.skill` | calibration | `dcm-checklist-reviewer.skill` | 2026-05-02 | 🟑 stale (30d) | +| `dem-config-builder.skill` | diagnostics | `dem-config-checklist-reviewer.skill` | 2026-05-02 | 🟑 stale (30d) | | `dfmea-builder.skill` | quality | `dfmea-checklist-reviewer.skill` | 2026-05-01 | 🟑 stale (30d) | | `dia-builder.skill` | safety | `dia-checklist-reviewer.skill` | 2026-05-01 | 🟑 stale (30d) | -| `dtc-catalog-builder.skill` | diagnostics | `dtc-catalog-checklist-reviewer.skill` | 2026-05-02 | 🟒 fresh | +| `dtc-catalog-builder.skill` | diagnostics | `dtc-catalog-checklist-reviewer.skill` | 2026-05-02 | 🟑 stale (30d) | | `fishbone-builder.skill` | quality | `fishbone-checklist-reviewer.skill` | 2026-05-01 | 🟑 stale (30d) | -| `flexray-config-builder.skill` | comms | `flexray-config-checklist-reviewer.skill` | 2026-05-02 | 🟒 fresh | +| `flexray-config-builder.skill` | comms | `flexray-config-checklist-reviewer.skill` | 2026-05-02 | 🟑 stale (30d) | | `fmeda-builder.skill` | safety | `fmeda-checklist-reviewer.skill` | 2026-05-01 | 🟑 stale (30d) | | `fsc-builder.skill` | safety | `fsc-checklist-reviewer.skill` | 2026-05-01 | 🟑 stale (30d) | -| `gateway-routing-builder.skill` | comms | `gateway-routing-checklist-reviewer.skill` | 2026-05-02 | 🟒 fresh | +| `gateway-routing-builder.skill` | comms | `gateway-routing-checklist-reviewer.skill` | 2026-05-02 | 🟑 stale (30d) | | `hara-builder.skill` | safety | `hara-checklist-reviewer.skill` | 2026-05-01 | 🟑 stale (30d) | | `hsi-builder.skill` | safety | `hsi-checklist-reviewer.skill` | 2026-05-01 | 🟑 stale (30d) | | `hw-architecture-builder.skill` | safety | `hw-architecture-checklist-reviewer.skill` | 2026-05-01 | 🟑 stale (30d) | | `hw-safety-reqs-builder.skill` | safety | `hw-safety-reqs-checklist-reviewer.skill` | 2026-05-01 | 🟑 stale (30d) | | `incident-response-plan-builder.skill` | cyber | `incident-response-plan-checklist-reviewer.skill` | 2026-05-01 | 🟑 stale (30d) | | `item-definition-builder.skill` | safety | `item-def-checklist-reviewer.skill` | 2026-05-01 | 🟑 stale (30d) | -| `ldf-builder.skill` | comms | `ldf-checklist-reviewer.skill` | 2026-05-02 | 🟒 fresh | -| `lessons-learned-builder.skill` | program-mgmt | `lessons-learned-checklist-reviewer.skill` | 2026-05-02 | 🟒 fresh | -| `mbse-model-architecture-builder.skill` | mbse | `mbse-model-architecture-checklist-reviewer.skill` | 2026-05-02 | 🟒 fresh | -| `mbse-requirements-allocation-builder.skill` | mbse | `mbse-requirements-allocation-checklist-reviewer.skill` | 2026-05-02 | 🟒 fresh | -| `mbse-system-context-builder.skill` | mbse | `mbse-system-context-checklist-reviewer.skill` | 2026-05-02 | 🟒 fresh | +| `ldf-builder.skill` | comms | `ldf-checklist-reviewer.skill` | 2026-05-02 | 🟑 stale (30d) | +| `lessons-learned-builder.skill` | program-mgmt | `lessons-learned-checklist-reviewer.skill` | 2026-05-02 | 🟑 stale (30d) | +| `mbse-model-architecture-builder.skill` | mbse | `mbse-model-architecture-checklist-reviewer.skill` | 2026-05-02 | 🟑 stale (30d) | +| `mbse-requirements-allocation-builder.skill` | mbse | `mbse-requirements-allocation-checklist-reviewer.skill` | 2026-05-02 | 🟑 stale (30d) | +| `mbse-system-context-builder.skill` | mbse | `mbse-system-context-checklist-reviewer.skill` | 2026-05-02 | 🟑 stale (30d) | | `msa-gage-rr-builder.skill` | quality | `msa-gage-rr-checklist-reviewer.skill` | 2026-05-01 | 🟑 stale (30d) | -| `odx-builder.skill` | diagnostics | `odx-checklist-reviewer.skill` | 2026-05-02 | 🟒 fresh | +| `odx-builder.skill` | diagnostics | `odx-checklist-reviewer.skill` | 2026-05-02 | 🟑 stale (30d) | | `pfmea-builder.skill` | quality | `pfmea-checklist-reviewer.skill` | 2026-05-01 | 🟑 stale (30d) | | `ppap-package-builder.skill` | quality | `ppap-checklist-reviewer.skill` | 2026-05-01 | 🟑 stale (30d) | | `safety-case-builder.skill` | safety | `safety-case-checklist-reviewer.skill` | 2026-05-01 | 🟑 stale (30d) | -| `safety-gate-review-builder.skill` | program-mgmt | `safety-gate-review-checklist-reviewer.skill` | 2026-05-02 | 🟒 fresh | +| `safety-gate-review-builder.skill` | program-mgmt | `safety-gate-review-checklist-reviewer.skill` | 2026-05-02 | 🟑 stale (30d) | | `safety-plan-builder.skill` | safety | `safety-plan-checklist-reviewer.skill` | 2026-05-01 | 🟑 stale (30d) | -| `safety-program-risk-register-builder.skill` | program-mgmt | `safety-program-risk-register-checklist-reviewer.skill` | 2026-05-02 | 🟒 fresh | +| `safety-program-risk-register-builder.skill` | program-mgmt | `safety-program-risk-register-checklist-reviewer.skill` | 2026-05-02 | 🟑 stale (30d) | | `secure-coding-guidelines-builder.skill` | cyber | `secure-coding-guidelines-checklist-reviewer.skill` | 2026-05-01 | 🟑 stale (30d) | | `sotif-analysis-builder.skill` | sotif | `sotif-analysis-checklist-reviewer.skill` | 2026-05-01 | 🟑 stale (30d) | | `sotif-validation-strategy-builder.skill` | sotif | `sotif-validation-strategy-checklist-reviewer.skill` | 2026-05-01 | 🟑 stale (30d) | @@ -68,25 +68,26 @@ _Auto-regenerated by `automotive-skills-daily-standup` (2026-06-01 PLAN run)._ | `sw-fmea-builder.skill` | safety | `sw-fmea-checklist-reviewer.skill` | 2026-05-01 | 🟑 stale (30d) | | `sw-hsis-builder.skill` | safety | `sw-hsis-checklist-reviewer.skill` | 2026-05-01 | 🟑 stale (30d) | | `sw-sr-builder.skill` | safety | `sw-sr-checklist-reviewer.skill` | 2026-05-01 | 🟑 stale (30d) | -| `sysml-activity-diagram-builder.skill` | sysml | `sysml-activity-diagram-checklist-reviewer.skill` | 2026-05-02 | 🟒 fresh | -| `sysml-block-diagram-builder.skill` | sysml | `sysml-block-diagram-checklist-reviewer.skill` | 2026-05-02 | 🟒 fresh | -| `sysml-requirement-diagram-builder.skill` | sysml | `sysml-requirement-diagram-checklist-reviewer.skill` | 2026-05-02 | 🟒 fresh | -| `sysml-state-machine-builder.skill` | sysml | `sysml-state-machine-checklist-reviewer.skill` | 2026-05-02 | 🟒 fresh | +| `sysml-activity-diagram-builder.skill` | sysml | `sysml-activity-diagram-checklist-reviewer.skill` | 2026-05-02 | 🟑 stale (30d) | +| `sysml-block-diagram-builder.skill` | sysml | `sysml-block-diagram-checklist-reviewer.skill` | 2026-05-02 | 🟑 stale (30d) | +| `sysml-requirement-diagram-builder.skill` | sysml | `sysml-requirement-diagram-checklist-reviewer.skill` | 2026-05-02 | 🟑 stale (30d) | +| `sysml-state-machine-builder.skill` | sysml | `sysml-state-machine-checklist-reviewer.skill` | 2026-05-02 | 🟑 stale (30d) | | `tara-builder.skill` | cyber | `tara-checklist-reviewer.skill` | 2026-05-01 | 🟑 stale (30d) | -| `test-case-catalog-builder.skill` | v&v | `test-case-catalog-checklist-reviewer.skill` | 2026-05-02 | 🟒 fresh | -| `traceability-matrix-builder.skill` | v&v | `traceability-matrix-checklist-reviewer.skill` | 2026-05-02 | 🟒 fresh | +| `test-case-catalog-builder.skill` | v&v | `test-case-catalog-checklist-reviewer.skill` | 2026-05-02 | 🟑 stale (30d) | +| `traceability-matrix-builder.skill` | v&v | `traceability-matrix-checklist-reviewer.skill` | 2026-05-02 | 🟑 stale (30d) | | `triggering-conditions-builder.skill` | sotif | `triggering-conditions-checklist-reviewer.skill` | 2026-05-01 | 🟑 stale (30d) | | `tsc-builder.skill` | safety | `tsc-checklist-reviewer.skill` | 2026-05-01 | 🟑 stale (30d) | | `uds-services-builder.skill` | diagnostics | `uds-services-checklist-reviewer.skill` | 2026-05-26 | 🟒 fresh | -| `validation-plan-builder.skill` | v&v | `validation-plan-checklist-reviewer.skill` | 2026-05-02 | 🟒 fresh | -| `verification-plan-builder.skill` | v&v | `verification-plan-checklist-reviewer.skill` | 2026-05-02 | 🟒 fresh | -| `vv-execution-report-builder.skill` | v&v | `vv-execution-report-checklist-reviewer.skill` | 2026-05-02 | 🟒 fresh | -| `wp-status-rollup-builder.skill` | program-mgmt | `wp-status-rollup-checklist-reviewer.skill` | 2026-05-02 | 🟒 fresh | +| `validation-plan-builder.skill` | v&v | `validation-plan-checklist-reviewer.skill` | 2026-05-02 | 🟑 stale (30d) | +| `verification-plan-builder.skill` | v&v | `verification-plan-checklist-reviewer.skill` | 2026-05-02 | 🟑 stale (30d) | +| `vv-execution-report-builder.skill` | v&v | `vv-execution-report-checklist-reviewer.skill` | 2026-05-02 | 🟑 stale (30d) | +| `wp-status-rollup-builder.skill` | program-mgmt | `wp-status-rollup-checklist-reviewer.skill` | 2026-05-02 | 🟑 stale (30d) | ## Summary -- Builders: **76** Β· Reviewers: **76** Β· Paired ratio: **100.0%** -- 🟒 fresh (paired, ≀30d): **38** -- 🟑 stale (paired, >30d): **38** +- Builders: **76** Β· Reviewers: **76** Β· Paired ratio: **100%** +- 🟒 fresh (paired, ≀30d): **2** +- 🟑 stale (paired, >30d): **74** - πŸ”΄ orphan (no paired reviewer): **0** - Domain spread: safety=15, quality=10, comms=8, cyber=6, autosar=5, diagnostics=5, program-mgmt=5, v&v=5, aspice=4, sysml=4, calibration=3, mbse=3, sotif=3 + diff --git a/docs/AUTONOMOUS_LOG.md b/docs/AUTONOMOUS_LOG.md index 2fed81c..2b57bb5 100644 --- a/docs/AUTONOMOUS_LOG.md +++ b/docs/AUTONOMOUS_LOG.md @@ -371,3 +371,19 @@ Standout finding is non-DoD and more impactful than the trigger gaps: the SKILL. **Velocity:** 23 commits, 24 distinct skills touched (skills + polish-log + examples), 3 weekly releases **Coverage:** 100% paired-reviewer (alias-aware), 7.9% examples (6/76 builders) **Notes:** First monthly KPI run β€” no prior snapshot for issue delta. SOTIF domain saw zero commits in May; flagged as a candidate for W24/W25 polish to avoid a two-month streak. + +## 2026-06-02 (autonomous run, POLISH) + +**Mode:** POLISH (Tuesday β€” first POLISH day of W23) +**Action:** W23 target #1 cs-concept-builder polish pass β€” re-evaluated against the (still-unchanged) archive, appended a W23-dated section to the existing polish-log, no .skill edits applied per the autonomous-edit allowlist. +**Files touched:** docs/skill-polish-log/cs-concept-builder.md (appended W23 section), STATUS.md (regenerated β€” flag column shifts only, no skill-data changes), docs/AUTONOMOUS_LOG.md (this entry) +**Tests:** N/A (no test suite in this repo yet) +**Skill count:** 76 builders / 76 reviewers / 100% paired +**Open issues:** 12 (unchanged from W23 PLAN: #2 needs-triage Β· #3–#10 weekly targets Β· #11 ci Β· #15/#16 W23 polish targets) +**Notes:** Picked cs-concept per the explicit W23 PLAN priority order β€” issue #4 is the longest-open polish issue in the repo (four-week carryover, originating in W20-T2). The archive is byte-identical to every prior inspection (inner mtimes 2026-05-01 07:55–07:58, top-level last touched in the 2026-05-01 seed commit f8d9799), so the W20 findings still stand exactly: description 784/1024 chars, frontmatter clean, AAICAN six-property list in canonical order inside the 400-char window, but the three formal trigger phrases `CSR derivation` (offset 607), `CAL allocation` (absent), and `CSI handoff` (only the parenthesized long-form at 497) all miss the strict W20 DoD. The W20-drafted rewrite (~970 chars, folds all three back into the first 400 chars plus two casual framings) would close the issue in one commit but it touches ~600 of the 784 description chars β€” same "editorial restructure, not surgical fix" judgement applied to hara-builder's W22 carryover. Per the standup's "typo / over-length / missing required field" allowlist, none of the three triggers fire here, so no archive edit was committed. STATUS regen: prior generator's domain map needed two tweaks (fmeda β†’ safety, msa-gage-rr / spc-chart β†’ quality, and the program-mgmt prefix rule had to fire BEFORE the broader safety- rule so safety-program-risk-register and safety-gate-review wouldn't false-match as safety). Domain spread now exactly matches the W22-RELEASE STATUS (safety=15, quality=10, comms=8, cyber=6, autosar=5, diagnostics=5, program-mgmt=5, v&v=5, aspice=4, sysml=4, calibration=3, mbse=3, sotif=3). Fresh/stale flags shifted today: as of 2026-06-02 the May-02-touched skills are now 31 days old, so only autosar-swc (2026-05-21) and uds-services (2026-05-26) remain 🟒 β€” 2 fresh / 74 stale on the headline. +**Follow-ups:** +- Wed POLISH should pick W23 target #2 aspice-assessment-builder (#5, also a four-week carryover, identical shape risk). +- Issue #4 should be closed by the human one way or the other β€” accept the W20 rewrite (closes the file), or close as "won't fix (outside autonomous scope)" to break the loop. A fifth POLISH pass next month will produce the same log entry. +- The classifier-extraction target (#10, W23 target #3) is still inline-Python; today's regen needed manual rule-order tweaks to match the prior STATUS exactly. A real `scripts/classify_skill.py` with a golden-file test would catch the ordering bug at PR time instead of after the fact. +- W23 target #4 fmeda-builder (#15) and #5 tara-builder (#16) are the fresh stale-cohort picks; Thu POLISH slot or W24 carryover depending on aspice-assessment workload tomorrow. +- Issue #2 ("goodd") still un-actioned; will continue to flag for human triage. diff --git a/docs/skill-polish-log/cs-concept-builder.md b/docs/skill-polish-log/cs-concept-builder.md index 050c750..8bda71b 100644 --- a/docs/skill-polish-log/cs-concept-builder.md +++ b/docs/skill-polish-log/cs-concept-builder.md @@ -146,3 +146,108 @@ phrases in the first 400 chars) is now the second consecutive POLISH finding β€” `hara-builder` (W20-T1, Tue) and `cs-concept-builder` (W20-T2, today) both shipped this same shape. Worth flagging in the next PLAN as a suite-wide DoD audit candidate rather than per-skill chasing. + +--- + +## 2026-06-02 β€” W23 POLISH pass (four-week carryover from W20) + +**Mode:** POLISH (Tuesday) +**File reviewed:** `skills/cs-concept-builder.skill` (ZIP archive; inner SKILL.md is 9,760 bytes / 133 lines). +**Tracking issue:** [#4](https://github.com/jherrodthomas/automotive-skills-suite/issues/4) (open, four-week carryover). +**Plan reference:** target #1 in `docs/weekly/WEEK-2026-W23.md` (top of W23 priority list). + +### File-state check vs. previous passes + +The archive is unchanged since the W20 inspection β€” every inner-file mtime is +`2026-05-01 07:55–07:58`, the SKILL.md is still 9,760 bytes / 133 lines, and the +top-level `.skill` was last touched by the initial seed commit f8d97993 on +2026-05-01. No drift, no regressions, nothing to undo. + +Re-ran the W20 trigger-coverage check fresh against the current bytes rather +than trusting the prior log: + +| DoD check (W20) | This pass | +|---|---| +| Description ≀ 1024 chars | **PASS** β€” 784 chars (unchanged, ~240 headroom) | +| Frontmatter has required fields (`name`, `description`) | **PASS** | +| AAICAN list intact in canonical order | **PASS** β€” all six properties present at offsets 255 / 271 / 286 / 297 / 314 / 328 (all inside the 400-char window) | +| `Cybersecurity Concept` in first 400 chars | **PASS** β€” offset 38 | +| `ISO/SAE 21434` in first 400 chars | **PASS** β€” offset 24 | +| `six security properties` in first 400 chars | **PASS** β€” offset 230 | +| `CSR` in first 400 chars | **PASS** β€” offset 360 (verb form, not the noun phrase `CSR derivation`) | +| `CAL` standalone | **MARGINAL** β€” offset 410, just outside the 400-char window | +| `CSR derivation` (formal trigger) in first 400 chars | **FAIL** β€” offset 607 (same gap W20 found; the noun phrase only appears inside the "Use this skill whenever the user mentions…" trigger list) | +| `CAL allocation` (formal trigger) anywhere in description | **FAIL** β€” literal noun phrase absent entirely. Closest is the verb form `allocates CAL per architectural element` at offset 400. | +| `CSI handoff` (plain form) in description | **FAIL** β€” only the parenthesized form `CSI (Cybersecurity Implementation) hand-off` appears, at offset 497. | +| Typo scan (`teh recieve seperate occured definately accomodate begining wether adress arguement existance reccommend reccomend`) | **PASS** β€” no hits. | + +Archive file-tree cross-check against `unzip -l` matches the "Files in this +skill" block in the SKILL.md footer exactly β€” same nine entries +(`SKILL.md`, `scripts/{generate_cs_concept.py, cs_goals_reader.py, recalc.py, +office/{__init__.py, soffice.py}}`, `references/{methodology.md, +csr_templates.md}`, `examples/sample_cs_concept_input_esc.json`). No +dbc-builder-style packaging drift here. + +### Autonomous-edit allowlist decision + +The standup spec defines the autonomous-edit allowlist narrowly: **typo, +description > 1024 chars, missing required frontmatter field**. None of the +three triggers fire here: + +- Description is 784 chars β€” well under cap. +- Both required frontmatter keys (`name`, `description`) are present. +- Zero typos in the SKILL.md body or frontmatter. + +The three open DoD findings are all editorial trigger-coverage rewrites of the +description, identical to the gaps caught in the W20 entry. Applying the +W20-proposed rewrite (~970 chars, reshuffles `CSR derivation` / `CAL +allocation` / `CSI handoff` into the first 400 chars and adds two casual +framings) would touch roughly **600 of the 784 description chars** β€” the same +"editorial restructure, not surgical fix" judgement the W22 hara-builder pass +applied to its proposed rewrite, and outside the standup's "small and shipped +beats big and broken" rule. + +**No edits committed this run.** Findings carry forward unchanged. + +### Why this is the fourth straight pass without a code edit + +W20 (2026-05-13) drafted the rewrite. W21 PLAN deprioritized cs-concept in +favour of newer targets; no POLISH touch. W22 PLAN re-included cs-concept as +target #4 but the actual W22 POLISH cycle (uds β†’ dfmea β†’ hara) consumed all +three slots before reaching it β€” flagged in the W22 RELEASE journal as the +explicit reason cs-concept must lead W23. W23 PLAN promoted it to target #1, +which is why today's pass exists. + +The pattern is now clear and worth stating out loud: **the cs-concept-builder +description is functionally fine** (84 chars over budget would change that; +missing frontmatter would change that; typos would change that) **but it +fails one specific DoD that the autonomous loop is not permitted to fix**. +Either the human approves the W20 rewrite and this issue closes, or the DoD +gets relaxed in a future PLAN, or the issue stays in carryover indefinitely. +A fifth POLISH pass next month would produce the same log entry for the same +reasons β€” diminishing returns are real here. + +### Severity roll-up (unchanged from W20) + +| Finding | Severity | Action | +|---|---|---| +| `CAL allocation` absent from description | low | W20-proposed rewrite drafted; await human review | +| `CSR derivation` outside first 400 chars | low | folded into the same proposed rewrite | +| `CSI handoff` plain form absent | low (optional) | folded into the same proposed rewrite | +| Casual framings thin / not verbatim | low (optional) | folded into the same proposed rewrite | + +### Follow-ups for the human + +1. **Decide on the W20-proposed rewrite of the description** (block quote in + the 2026-05-13 entry above). If approved, it lands as a one-shot edit and + issue [#4](https://github.com/jherrodthomas/automotive-skills-suite/issues/4) + closes the same day. If rejected, the issue should be closed as `won't fix + (outside autonomous scope)` to break the four-week loop. +2. **Suite-wide DoD audit** for the trigger-coverage gap is still recommended + (`hara-builder`, `cs-concept-builder`, and likely `tara-builder` / + `fmeda-builder` / `aspice-assessment-builder` carry the same shape). One + focused audit replaces five carryover loops. Captured in the W23 PLAN + notes; still not scheduled. +3. **Optional:** fold the autonomous-edit allowlist into the standup spec + explicitly so future runs have a citeable rule for declining editorial + rewrites without re-deriving the decision each visit.