diff --git a/STATUS.md b/STATUS.md index a9f69fe..198a6e8 100644 --- a/STATUS.md +++ b/STATUS.md @@ -1,6 +1,6 @@ # STATUS — automotive-skills-suite -_Auto-generated 2026-05-27 by automotive-skills-daily-standup (POLISH run)._ +_Auto-generated 2026-05-28 by automotive-skills-daily-standup (POLISH run)._ | Builder | Domain | Paired Reviewer | Last Touched | Flag | |---|---|---|---|---| diff --git a/docs/AUTONOMOUS_LOG.md b/docs/AUTONOMOUS_LOG.md index d0ad3a2..8cf78df 100644 --- a/docs/AUTONOMOUS_LOG.md +++ b/docs/AUTONOMOUS_LOG.md @@ -292,3 +292,18 @@ Standout finding is non-DoD and more impactful than the trigger gaps: the SKILL. - Fri DOCS run should roll W22 polish commits into CHANGELOG. - Consider closing W22 tracking issues (#3, #4, #5, #9, #12) once human reviews polish-log entries. Auto-runs do NOT close issues per hard rules. - If a future POLISH pass wants to extend the dfmea-builder description with casual trigger phrasings, ~350 chars of headroom remain under the 1024 cap. + +## 2026-05-28 (autonomous run, POLISH) + +**Mode:** POLISH +**Action:** W22 #2 hara-builder polish pass — re-evaluated against current archive, appended W22 dated section to existing polish-log, no .skill edits applied per autonomous-edit allowlist. +**Files touched:** docs/skill-polish-log/hara-builder.md (appended), STATUS.md (regen — date-stamp delta only, underlying skill data unchanged), docs/AUTONOMOUS_LOG.md (this entry) +**Tests:** N/A (no test suite in this repo yet) +**Skill count:** 76 builders / 76 reviewers / 100% paired +**Open issues:** 11 +**Notes:** Picked hara-builder per W22 plan target #2 (issue #3, three-week carryover) — yesterday's dfmea entry overstated W22 coverage when it claimed "W22 polish phase effectively complete." Three of the W22 plan targets (hara, cs-concept, aspice-assessment) had only W20-dated polish-log entries, and the W22 plan DoD explicitly asks for a fresh per-skill audit. Today's pick was hara because: (a) issue #3 is the longest-open polish issue, (b) all three remaining carryovers shared a last-touched date so plan order broke the tie, (c) hara has the densest SKILL.md of the three. Re-ran the trigger-coverage and char-count checks against the current archive — file is byte-identical to the W20 inspection (`2026-04-28 07:08` mtime preserved), so the W20 findings still stand: description 911/1024 chars, frontmatter clean, 6 of 7 strict trigger phrases inside the 400-char window, "safety goal" misses at char 454. The W20 entry already drafted an editorial rewrite that would close all three open findings; today's entry refrains from applying it because the change exceeds the autonomous-edit allowlist (typo / over-length / missing required field) and the suite-wide trigger-coverage DoD audit flagged in earlier passes is the better vehicle. STATUS regen: hit the same `item-definition→item-def` and `ppap-package→ppap` pairing alias overrides; preserved both to keep 76/76 paired headline intact (this is the 4th run where the overrides have been needed; issue #10 to freeze the classifier remains open). +**Follow-ups:** +- Tomorrow (Fri) DOCS: roll W22 polish commits (uds, dfmea, hara) into CHANGELOG; create example//README.md stubs for the three touched skills if absent. +- Open issues #3, #4, #5, #9, #12 all now have W22 polish-log coverage (or in the case of #4/#5 still need a fresh W22 visit) — flag for human triage at human convenience. Auto-runs do NOT close issues per hard rules. +- cs-concept (#4) and aspice-assessment (#5) still owe a W22-dated polish-log entry; depending on Fri DOCS and Sat RELEASE workload, one or both may slip to W23 — accept and move on. +- Issue #10 (classifier freeze) is now 7 runs old; STATUS.md generator is still ~50 lines of inline Python in each commit. Strongly recommend Mon W23 PLAN allocate one tooling slot to extract `scripts/classify_skill.py` so future POLISH runs can `python scripts/classify_skill.py > STATUS.md` instead of carrying the alias map by hand. diff --git a/docs/skill-polish-log/hara-builder.md b/docs/skill-polish-log/hara-builder.md index 5850dd0..d281115 100644 --- a/docs/skill-polish-log/hara-builder.md +++ b/docs/skill-polish-log/hara-builder.md @@ -108,3 +108,87 @@ names it). All five DoD triggers + the bonus "concept phase" hit the description **No code edits committed in this run.** Issue #3 stays open with this log linked from the journal entry. Next autonomous touch on this skill: probably W21 if it stays in the LRT bucket, otherwise close on human approval of the rewrite. + +--- + +## 2026-05-28 — W22 POLISH pass (carryover from W20) + +**Mode:** POLISH (Thursday) +**File reviewed:** `skills/hara-builder.skill` (ZIP archive; SKILL.md is 12,273 bytes / 146 lines). +**Tracking issue:** [#3](https://github.com/jherrodthomas/automotive-skills-suite/issues/3) (open). +**Plan reference:** target #2 in `docs/weekly/WEEK-2026-W22.md` (carryover from W20). + +### File-state check vs. previous pass + +The archive has not changed since the W20 pass (`2026-04-28 07:08` mtime on every +entry inside the `.skill`). The SKILL.md byte size, line count, and frontmatter all +match what the 2026-05-12 entry above recorded. So everything that was true then is +still true now — no regressions, no drift. + +Re-ran the trigger-coverage check fresh against the current file rather than trusting +the prior log: + +| DoD check (W20) | This pass | +|---|---| +| Description ≤ 1024 chars | **PASS** — 911 chars (unchanged) | +| Frontmatter has required fields (`name`, `description`) | **PASS** | +| `HARA` in first 400 chars | **PASS** — char 71 | +| `hazard analysis` in first 400 chars | **PASS** — char 34 | +| `ASIL` in first 400 chars | **PASS** — char 285 | +| `item definition` in first 400 chars | **PASS** — char 94 | +| `safety goal` in first 400 chars | **FAIL** — char 454 (same gap the W20 pass found) | +| `ISO 26262` in first 400 chars | **PASS** — char 24 | +| `concept phase` (bonus, not strict DoD) | **FAIL** — char 672 | + +Also did a fresh typo scan (`teh recieve seperate occured definately accomodate +begining wether`) — no hits. Step headers all use em-dashes consistently (Step 1 +through Step 5). Archive file tree matches the "Files in this skill" block at the +bottom of SKILL.md exactly (cross-checked against `unzip -l`). + +### Autonomous-edit allowlist decision + +The autonomous-edit allowlist is narrow: **typo / description > 1024 chars / missing +required frontmatter field**. None of the three conditions hold here. The only open +DoD gap — `safety goal` reordered into the first 400 chars — is an editorial sentence +re-ordering, not a surgical fix. Per the standing rule ("NEVER do large refactors — +small and shipped beats big and broken"), I am leaving the .skill file untouched. + +**No edits committed in this run.** The proposed rewrite from the 2026-05-12 entry +above remains the recommended human action. + +### Why not just apply the W20-proposed rewrite this run? + +Two reasons. (a) The proposed rewrite touches ~600 chars of the 911-char description +— that crosses the line from "small obvious fix" into "editorial restructure," which +the spec reserves for human review. (b) The rewrite was drafted two POLISH cycles +ago and the suite-wide trigger-coverage pattern (hara, cs-concept, aspice — three +in a row, see notes at the bottom of the W20 entries) has been flagged for a +suite-wide DoD audit in W21/W22 PLANs. A point fix here would short-circuit that +audit before it lands. + +### Severity roll-up (unchanged from W20) + +| Finding | Severity | Action | +|---|---|---| +| `safety goal` outside first 400 chars | low | proposed rewrite drafted in W20 entry; await human review | +| Long "Produces..." enumeration clause | low | folded into the same proposed rewrite | +| No `concept phase` trigger up front | low (optional) | folded into the same proposed rewrite | + +### Follow-ups for the human + +1. **Approve or modify the W20 proposed rewrite of the description** (block quote near + the end of the 2026-05-12 entry). If approved, it can land as a one-shot edit and + issue [#3](https://github.com/jherrodthomas/automotive-skills-suite/issues/3) + closes the same day. +2. **Decide whether the suite-wide trigger-coverage DoD audit is W23 PLAN-eligible.** + Three consecutive POLISH passes (hara → cs-concept → aspice) have shipped the + same shape; one focused audit pass is cheaper than chasing individual skills. +3. **Optional:** consider adding `concept phase` to the canonical trigger phrase + list applied during the audit, since the same gap is likely present on + `fsc-builder` and `tsc-builder` too. + +This is the second POLISH visit to `hara-builder` and the file is unchanged between +visits. If the human review of the W20 rewrite does not land before next month, +the LRT rotation will surface this skill a third time — recommend either closing +issue #3 with a "won't fix (within autonomous scope)" note, or merging the W20 +rewrite, to break the loop.